Tonight in Seattle:  

The Cinematics — A Strange Education

The Cinematics -- A Strange Education



The new album by Bloc Party The Cinematics contains 12 glossy, well-polished regurgitations of the last few years' worth of alterna-radio hits. Yawn. It's not that the Scottish band has made a bad album; it's just that it's so damn familiar, and the pop-rock innovations of 2004 are now the old hats of 2007. Perhaps The Bravery The Cinematics didn't get the memo.

The songs on A Strange Education are dripping with suave production, fierce hooks, jangly guitar licks, danceable beats, and all the ingredients of a hit record among the mainstream "alternative" set. It is not unlikely that the snappily-dressed members of Kasabian The Cinematics will find themselves tearing up the charts stateside on the strength of songs like "Chase" and "Keep Forgetting," if recent history is any indication of the current tastes of our masses. And surely those masses will delight in adding another 12 smash hits to their Killers-infested playlists. The rest of us, though — the ones hungry for new flavors — would best pass on this, if for nothing else then for the hazard that one may risk by listening to this record while, say, driving or operating heavy machinery.

Editors The Cinematics keep things up-tempo for the course of the album, save for the final song, "Home," which sees vocalist Scott Rinning attempt his best Thom Yorke as he visits the upper range of his voice. At times, he more closely resembles Kermit the Frog during this bare-bones finisher. Up to this point, his vocals have been smooth and steady; this "Hidden Bonus Track" throws a little imperfection and vulnerability into the mix, but it's actually somewhat welcome after the string of flawless ringers that precede it.

Its Brit pop, indie rock or what ever you want to label it - You dont get many Jeff Buckleys to the dollar you know - why are you, and your not the lone critic here, obsessed with finding the next new sound, thing or whatever - as a critic you should know that 99.9% of it has all been done before. Ive seen the cinematics play many times and I firmly believe that they are a special band. Strange Education is their first dip in the pond, there is a lot better still in the locker. Have you seen them live??? If you havent, I suggest you do the next time they around your neck of the woods.

Nope, haven't seen them live, and should I get to, I'll be glad to post a live review. I'll be the first to admit that many bands fail to impress on record when in fact they kill live — or vice versa. As this is a review of the album, what they do live is irrelevant here. And as for looking for the next Jeff Buckley, that's a strange comment considering I've been pretty clear on here how I feel about him...

Everyone has a right to an opinion. Mine = This album blows.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.