LIVE SHOW REVIEWS
Goodness pacify my heart
The last time I saw Seattle band Goodness, Clinton was still in the White House, I was single and childless, and the band completely knocked me out with their well-crafted, highly rocking set. A lot has changed since then, but damn if the band didn't send me for an emotional trip down memory lane while packing a wallop as fresh and vibrant as it ever was back in the late 90s when last we rocked together.
For a little background: Goodness formed in the mid-90s and featured powerful Hammerbox front woman Carrie Akre on vocals. They rose to Seattle adoration and played about for several years, including Bumbershoot and selling out the Showbox, before disbanding in 1999. I've never understood why they didn't get Really Huge; my working theory is they came between two Seattle bandwagons, too late for grunge, too early for the post-grunge Seattle music resurgence of the mid-aughts.
But no matter: those of us who were here for Goodness *loved* Goodness. They were one of the two bands I relentlessly stalked when I first moved to Seattle (the other being the Amateur Lovers, who also reunited for a show not long ago).
I wasn’t the only one. The Showbox was rocking, jumping, packed and pumped with fans who have sorely missed Goodness over the past near decade. One superfan in particular drunkenly introduced himself to my fellow-Goodness-fan-pal Jenny and me as “John” before the show. After fawning for several moments (“You two are so beautiful,” he slurred), he waxed nostalgic about seeing Goodness at Rock Candy back in the day and let all those within earshot know that he planned to "mosh and slam" throughout the set. Lucky us. And did dude ever make good on that unfortunate promise. He failed and wacked and fell into us and all the unfortunate souls within stumbing distance.
A few songs in it became clear that my well-placed pointy elbows weren’t going to deter him; the high of Goodness and perhaps one-too-many Captain Morgan and Cokes evidently left him impervious to pain and the wilting stares of those around him. Jenny and I wriggled our way to the center throng and spent the remainder of the set smack in front of the incredible Ms. Akre.
John-the-flailer might have been annoying, but the end justified his wild man means: standing in front of Carrie Akre in her full-on rocker glory was astonishing, amazingly, incredibly glorious. Gush gush gush.
Then Garth swooped in -- or should I say, out -- and did one of the coolest things I've ever witnessed a guitar player do (and I've seen _a_LOT of guitar player antics). Garth jumped offstage and right onto “John,” tackling him and ejecting him from the front of the audience before rejoining the band onstage. It was So. Bad. Ass. Rumor has it a bottle was thrown onstage, but if so I missed that part. Yay to Garth for making sure all the fans in front could enjoy the set! No sense letting one out-of-control annoying superfan ruin it for the rest of us.
Luckily the rest of the superfandom was of a kinder, gentler ilk. At the beginning of the show Akre proclaimed, “We have always had the greatest fans,” and ya know, I’m inclined to agree. The whole night had the vibe of a celebration more than just a show. Everyone was screaming and cheering and singing along, completely un-ironically relishing the band.
Goodness responded in kind. They just know the art of a performance, starting with good songs and working up to great ones, taunting the crowd to jump and sweat. As my friend Jenny commented after the show, “It’s been years since I’ve been to a ROCK show like that.” It was a joyous and unabashed performance, and the bouncing of the spring-loaded floor of the Showbox as we all jumped along with the amazing music made my spirit feel buoyant.
It was strange, hearing Carrie’s superwise lyrics, which provided much of the soundtrack to my single adulthood, now that I'm married and a mama. I found myself wondering if Carrie found it hard to sing them, now that she’s the same. Then she dedicated “Boy Glory” to all of her and Fiia’s exes. “Oh yes, I went there,” she laughed, thanking God for their current husband and boyfriend. It was so sassy, and I think she sang those lyrics like she meant them even more than ever from the other side of them. And I felt the same way, making the night seem even a little more psychic and surreal.
Favorites "Superwise," "Eveready," and “Labor Day” were total crowd pleasers, and the rousing finale of "Wicked Eye," which had Fiia and Friel killing the rhythm section, mounted the band into a frenzy of a finale before leaving the stage, ending the show with an exclamation point instead of a period. There was no ambiguity of a second encore; clearly, they had concluded with a Huge Big Bang.
Luckily it wasn't the final finale. Goodness announced they have a couple more shows forthcoming: August 23rd at the Mural Amphitheatre, and November 22nd at the Tractor. Does this mean the band's reunion might be semi-permanent? I have no idea, but I'm hopeful.
The setlist:
Viva le High
Anthem
Pretender
Smoking
Garth Rock
Hic-Up
Bitterman
Goodbye
Lost
Eveready
Boyglory
Sex and Rebellion
Sincerely Yours
Superwise
----------------------------
Labor Day
Big Wheel
These Days
Wicked Eye
imaginary dana said on August 13, 2008:
Aww, thanks Mike! Your photos are amazing -- especially this one:

That is incredible work (and I know how raucous the crowd was around you when you took it).
a goodness fan said on August 13, 2008:
Wow, what an awesome truthful review! I was there and had the opportunity of meeting and having my pic taken with each and every member of Goodness, it was GREAT. They were all so nice and friendly. I am also a fan from back in the day and believe that last time I had a chance to see them was @ the old Fenix underground. I am looking forward to the show on the 23rd, this time with more friends and children! :0
imaginary stella said on August 13, 2008:
Awwww, I am SO glad that Goodness will be playing more shows around town! Couldn't make this one as we had a wedding to go to (which was, of course, lovely - but I missed seeing Carrie too!). I heart this band so much and am thrilled to see them back in action!
Annette said on August 13, 2008:
It' funny,I found my Goodness cd a couple months ago in a box,slightly scratched from when I would play it over and over again years ago,it would skip some,but I put in the boise and it played no problem...I have been listening to that cd for 2 months straight,so imagine my pure freakin surprise when I found out they were back together,and playing the showbox...It was sooo awesome,they played all my favorites and sounded better than ever..Can't wait till the tractor show.thanks for letting me share..Sincerly yours,Annette
facts about rob said on August 14, 2008:
hey dana--
i have your scoop on why goodness never got huge like they should have.... the major's wanted carrie, but not the rest of the band, and she told them all to stuff it! (simplifying the story a bit, but that's how i heard it back in the day... happened to them more than once, if i remember correctly)....
Sheryl said on August 15, 2008:
Okay, so glad we all agree the Goodness show was incredible as always...they may need consider changing the name to Greatness! The music and lyrics are still totally relavent, the dynamic on stage was great and of course Carrie still rocks the mic. I too followed them throughout the 90s between Olympia and Bellingham and will definitely be at the Mural Amphitheatre show!
To put the superfan incident to bed...
I met John before the show too and he seemed nice but high. He also warned me about his moshing which would have been fine, except he was doing it while grabbing onto the girls in the front row - including me. At first he was just squeezing our shoulders, but was doing it so hard it was painful. Then he seemed to be trying to grab at our chests, was calling us so beautiful, and eventually grabbed our asses!
Since all attempts to push and shove John off us failed, I tried to motion for security several times - thank you for nothing Showbox, the guard was backstage seemingly doing nothing but ignoring me. Someone needed to do something, I was about a second from punching John in the face myself when a girl (friend of Johns?) came from no where and started getting into it with me! I think Garth saw what was up. Garth yelled at John (inaudibe to me) and flipped him off. John then grabbed my near empty beer bottle from the stage and threw it at Garth. It nearly hit him but instead got beer on Garths jeans. Thats when Garth jumped off stage and got the guy out of there. The girl seemed to go away too and after that we only had to deal with the usual moshers - no more grabbing onto our body parts.
I saw John out front after the show and my husband wanted to continue the conversation Garth had started, but I wouldnt tell him which guy it was to avoid another fight. I suspect this John guy was on X or something a tad harder than booze...I have never had anything like this happen at a show, especially Goodness! Like Carrie said - they do have the best fans...high energy, there to have a good time...not usually at the expense of anyone else. No matter what, I was not going to let anyone spoil the show for me and Garth - our hero - made sure that happened! Love the Goodness!
imaginary dana said on August 15, 2008:
Sheryl -- I think I remember you! My friend and I were standing right behind John before the show. He said something about being there with his wife, so maybe that's who was getting into it with you? I don't know. I loved reading your update from the front lines -- thanks for stopping by and sharing!
And yes to everything you said regarding lyrics, dynamics, etc. I am planning to go to the Mural and to bring my baby girl with me! Gotta get her started young, right? I just saw that Ms. Led is also on the bill. It's going to be an evening of incredible female rock stars for sures.
imaginary stella said on August 15, 2008:
Ages ago, when I wrote a review here about Ms. Led's debut, I recall comparing Lesli to Carrie -- in all the right ways. And now they're joining up for a show! The circle has come full...!
imaginary dana said on August 15, 2008:
@Michael -- agreed. Someone beyond me yelled, "Lookin' good, Fiia!!!" during the set. She is hot like fire (and so is her Ricky bass).
Mike Wilson said on August 13, 2008:
What an awesome review of an incredible show! Sorry you missed the opening bands, but make sure to catch My Life In Black & White next time they're in town. They were pretty incredible too!
It was wonderful to meet you... look after that cute little kid of yours! :)