Well, I wouldn't go that far. I think Vice just has it out for P4FK anyway. "Insistor" was a pretty great tune (albeit from The Loon, so I wouldn't condemn the band for eternity.
Not to say this will happen, but remember how much everyone hated Pinkerton when it came out. Heck, Rolling Stone ranked it as the #2 worst album of the year behind Bush. Sometimes the visceral first reactions are way off.
Walk It Off, to me, was a big disappointment but by no means was it a complete disaster (see: Ghostland Observatory).
Reviews
Erik Gonzalez said on April 14, 2008:
Well, I wouldn't go that far. I think Vice just has it out for P4FK anyway. "Insistor" was a pretty great tune (albeit from The Loon, so I wouldn't condemn the band for eternity.
Not to say this will happen, but remember how much everyone hated Pinkerton when it came out. Heck, Rolling Stone ranked it as the #2 worst album of the year behind Bush. Sometimes the visceral first reactions are way off.
Walk It Off, to me, was a big disappointment but by no means was it a complete disaster (see: Ghostland Observatory).