You're right. I couldn't even get all the way through the Katy Perry song.

Siouxsie, in the Goth-tastic "Fear of the Unknown" video, is my favorite, um, impression of this topic. But you didn't ask that.

Jill definitely better at kissing girls, and better at chord progressions.

Katy's song seems like something going on the girls gone wild bus. Plus I know its trendy and all, but I just really don't like the vocal effects going on the recording. If I want to hear robot singing I'll listen to MC Hawking thanks.

Both songs are actually pretty similar in that it fit the music trend of the time. Jill's song is a typical 90's alternative rock/pop song while Katy's song is a typical 2007/2008 electropop sound that's popular right now on the radio and charts. both have stupid lyrics yet are catchy and will be my added to my list of guilty pleasures. If I had to pick, Jill's song is better. However, Katy's song is good to listen to if you're driving or at a club.

i didnt like Jills song peronally
it was kind of wierd and blunt
katys verion was alittle more understandable.
she explained how she was curious and made it clear it was just something she wanted to try
jills on the otherhand made it seem like she went all the way with a girl and kept loving it and didnt want to go back to men.
plus katys verion is alot better to dance to

i didnt like Jills song peronally
it was kind of wierd and blunt
katys verion was alittle more understandable.
she explained how she was curious and made it clear it was just something she wanted to try
jills on the otherhand made it seem like she went all the way with a girl and kept loving it and didnt want to go back to men.
plus katys verion is alot better to dance to

"Okay, Katy, I know we just pulled you out of small-town Texas and you grew up listening to country, but believe us, this is REALLY how city folk act. This song will be a HUGE hit. Don't worry about your country lilt, we have computer editing for that. Just pretend like you're interested in other girls, this is how they act at clubs."

I know I'm the last person to make this judgment, but the Katy Perry song to me.

ChrisB, your link doesn't work. I'm assuming it's something along these lines.

I love how celebrity gossip has run rampant on TIG lately.

I accidentally double posted and it's not letting me delete the second comment, so all I can do is edit the text so I thought I'd fill it in with dribble instead of being identically repetitive. Perhaps a "delete comment" option is in order...pleeeeeeeease.

hmmm...not sure why the link didn't work, but this is what I meant to link to:

http://gawker.com/tag/katy-perry/?i=5019056&t=girl+on+girl-singers-shameful-christian-past